Srinagar, Nov 18: For some, it was the money accumulated over a lifetime of service. For others, it was the house they had built and the savings they had set aside for their children’s future. They invested it in land in Kashmir, believing they were securing something permanent. Years later, some discovered that the property they had paid for had allegedly been sold to others, transferred into different names or was simply beyond their possession.
The stories of retired Director of Fisheries Mufti Manzoor and Mohammad Aslam Andrabi, Vice Chairman of the J&K Muslim Personal Law Board, illustrate how alleged land fraud can turn a seemingly straightforward property purchase into years of uncertainty, financial distress and legal battles.
Manzoor said his family purchased land in Sampora around 2010 through a property dealer, paying Rs 7 lakh per kanal. The transactions, he said, were made through cheques, followed by registered sale documents and mutation in the names of family members.
But when the family returned to inspect the property, they found that part of the land had allegedly been taken over by someone else.
“When I asked him what was happening, he told me that a tehsildar had taken that one kanal and that he would give me land somewhere else in exchange. This went on for nearly a year,” Manzoor said.
A subsequent inquiry at the revenue department, he alleged, revealed that the land had been registered in another person’s name.
Manzoor said the problem was not confined to his family. He claimed to have records of at least 20 other people who had allegedly suffered similar losses, including a woman who invested her deceased husband’s gratuity and pension in land but could not locate the property, and another family that allegedly paid for six kanals without receiving possession.
“This is not just my case. We have land worth Rs 2.5 crore involved in this. I have records of at least 20 people who have suffered in the same way. I want the government to take this seriously and act against this land mafia just as it acted against the drug mafia,” he said.
For Andrabi, the alleged fraud meant losing a house worth around Rs 2.5 crore.
He said he was persuaded to sell his house after being promised land and a hotel in Pahalgam. The proposed investment was presented as an opportunity to build a business and secure his family’s future. Instead, he alleges, the money and property arrangements became entangled in a series of unfulfilled promises.
“I had sold my house. My children had completed their education, and both were studying medicine. I was shown a dream that a hotel would come up in Pahalgam. I sold my house, which was worth around Rs 2.5 crore, but nearly Rs 1 crore of my money remains stuck to this day. I have not been able to get out of this situation,” he said.
He alleged that the dealer subsequently offered him two shops in a proposed commercial building in exchange for Rs 1.60 crore. Neither the shops nor the land or documents, he said, were delivered.
The ordeal also affected his family. Andrabi said his younger brother, Syed Shabir, paid Rs 50 lakh after being promised land in Pahalgam four years ago. The promised transaction never materialised, and the money was not returned.
His brother later developed cancer and spent nine months undergoing treatment at Tata Memorial Hospital in Mumbai. Andrabi said the family repeatedly approached the dealer, asking him to return the money to help meet the treatment expenses.
“We went to the dealer not once but a hundred times, requesting him to help us in those circumstances and return at least some of the money so that my brother could afford his treatment. But every time we went, we returned humiliated,” he said. Riyaz Dar, the property dealer accused by Manzoor, said the two sides had been negotiating over the dispute for several years.
Dar claimed that Manzoor had accepted an alternative piece of land in exchange for the disputed property, signed an agreement and even constructed boundary walls on it.
Dar maintained that he was willing to resolve the dispute, either by providing the land covered by the registered documents or compensating Manzoor at the property’s current market value.
“I acknowledge the land I transferred to them. I am still ready to fulfil my responsibility under the registration. I am willing to go to the site and hand over the land. If they are no longer interested in that land, I am ready to compensate them,” he said.
He also maintained that some complainants had dealt with intermediaries rather than directly with him.
The victims’ accounts point to a recurring pattern in alleged property fraud: buyers relying on intermediaries, paying substantial sums and completing paperwork, only to face disputes over ownership, possession or subsequent transactions involving the same land. For many, the struggle does not end with discovering the alleged fraud. It continues through revenue offices, police stations and courts, with little certainty about when they might recover either the property or their money.
Crime Branch investigation
The dispute involving Manzoor has also figured in a criminal investigation. The Economic Offences Wing (EOW) Kashmir of the Crime Branch Jammu and Kashmir completed its investigation into the land fraud case in question and filed a chargesheet in December 2025.
SSP Economic Offences Wing Crime Branch Kashmir Abdul Waheed Shah confirmed that the investigation had been completed and a chargesheet filed before the court.
“A threadbare investigation in the case has been completed, which revealed involvement of revenue officials and land brokers. Subsequently, the case has been charged sheeted in court of law for judicial determination,” Shah told Greater Kashmir.
Shah also pointed to an increase in the number of people approaching the Crime Branch with land-related complaints over the past two years.
“Majority of complaints we received at the Crime Branch during the last two years have been mostly land-related matters,” he said.
In a separate migrant property fraud case, the EOW Kashmir has filed a chargesheet against five persons over the alleged fraudulent sale of 14 kanals and 3 marlas of land in Baramulla district.
The case, registered as FIR No. 34/2017, concerns land owned by Jawahar Lal Bhat at Mouza Wussan, Goshbugh Pattan. According to officials, the accused allegedly received payments exceeding Rs 1 crore but neither handed over possession nor returned the money. The investigation has alleged impersonation, fabrication of identity documents and misuse of a purported power of attorney. The chargesheet has been filed before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sopore.
For people such as Manzoor and Andrabi, however, the demand is not merely for investigations or legal proceedings. It is for the recovery of money earned over decades, and property they believe they had lawfully purchased.
Their experiences also underline the need for buyers to independently verify ownership and revenue records, registration documents and mutation entries before completing property transactions. But for those who have already lost their savings, such precautions offer little comfort.
